24 July 2014

English High Court judgment in ongoing Zambian dispute

On 15 July 2014, the High Court in London handed down a further judgment in the ongoing dispute between Konkola Copper Mines (KCM) and U&M Mining Zambia Ltd (U&M).

KCM owns a number of mines on the Zambian copper belt.  It is a Zambian company majority owned by Vendanta Resources Plc, which is listed on the London Stock Exchange.  The remaining stake in KCM is held by a company which is in turn majority owned by the Government of the Republic of Zambia.

The Government also holds a Golden Share.  U&M, which is a Zambian subsidiary of a Brazilian mining conglomerate, was contracted from around 2007 to operate one of KCM's mines.  From 2012, a number of disputes arose between the parties in relation to their various contractual arrangements, including in relation to invoices allegedly unpaid by KCM.

In common with other disputes between locally incorporated mining companies with parents in the UK or elsewhere, action has been taken in more than one jurisdiction.  The parties' disputes were referred to arbitration at the London Court of International Arbitration and there have been related court proceedings in Zambia, Brazil and London.

It appears from the English High Court judgments that there are currently several outstanding arbitral awards against KCM, totalling in excess of USD56 million, but that KCM is resisting enforcement of the first award in Zambia and brought proceedings in the English court seeking to challenge the second award on various grounds.  

It was the dismissal of KCM's challenge to that second award that was the subject of the latest English High Court judgment.  In another decision some two weeks prior, KCM had been directed to pay security for U&M's costs of defending that challenge. Of interest was the Court's reasoning that KCM, which was found itself to have insufficient liquid funds to pay U&M's costs and no assets in the jurisdiction, could not rely on the significant financial strength of its LSE listed parent to defeat the application as there were no undertakings in place from that parent company.

This is an engaging though apparently bitterly fought dispute and we will await any further developments with interest.

This article was written by Joanne Keillor, Senior Associate, London.  For further information please contact Joanne Keillor or your usual Herbert Smith Freehills contact.

11 July 2014

Japan-Australia Economic Partnership Agreement signed, text released

On Wednesday, 9 July, Japanese Prime Minister, Shinzo Abe, and Australian Prime Minister, Tony Abbott, signed the Japan-Australia Economic Partnership Agreement (JAEPA).

Following domestic approval processes in Australia and Japan, the JAEPA will come into force and 99.7% of Australia’s exports of resource, energy and manufacturing products will benefit from duty-free enter into Japan. All of Australia’s current resources, energy and manufactured goods exports with benefit from duty-free entry into Japan on full implementation of the JAEPA.

The JAEPA does not include investor-state dispute settlement (ISDS) provisions, offering cross-border investors protection against political risks such as expropriation of investment assets or profits and discrimination between cross-border investors and national investors.

The original article was prepared by Leon Chung, Partner, and Kate Lindeman, Solicitor, Sydney, and can be read here.

7 July 2014

ICSID claim filed against Indonesian Government

On 1 July, PT Newmont Nusa Tenggara and its majority Dutch shareholder Nusa Tenggara Partnership BV, announced that they have filed international investment arbitration proceedings against the Indonesian Government to seek relief from export restrictions that have halted production at the Batu Hijau mine and are said to have inflicted hardship and economic loss on PT Newmont Nusa Tenggara’s employees, contractors, and other stakeholders.

The claimants allege that the government’s imposition of new export conditions, a new export duty and a ban on the export of copper concentrate breach PT Newmont Nusa Tenggara’s Contract of Work with the Indonesian Government, and the bilateral investment treaty between Indonesia and the Netherlands. The claimants have indicated that they will seek interim injunctive relief, so that work at the mine can resume.

This claim follows an announcement earlier this year that Indonesia intended to cancel all of its 67 bilateral investment treaties, and draw up new treaties. The bilateral investment treaty between Indonesia and the Netherlands was among the first to be cancelled, with effect from July 2015 (though a sunset clause in the treaty means it will continue to apply for a period after that).

For further information, please contact Jay Leary, Partner, Brisbane, or your usual Herbert Smith Freehills contact.

4 July 2014

Baosteel and Aurizon in control of Aquila Resources

On Thursday, 3 July, Aurizon announced that Baosteel Resources Australia and Aurizon Operations (the Bidders) entered into a Takeover Implementation Agreement (TIA) with Aquila Resources (Aquila) to facilitate the change in control and management of Aquila to the Bidders.

Tony Poli (chairman and largest shareholder of Aquila) has agreed to sell his 28.9% stake in Aquila (a condition of the TIA), increasing the Bidders’ stake to 69.3%.  Mineral Resources also agreed to sell its $12.8% stake after failing to secure a merger deal with Aquila.

Under the TIA, Tony Poli and two directors of Aquila, Gordon Galt and Denise Goldsworthy, will resign from the Aquila board on or before 11 July and four of the Bidders’ nominees will be appointed.

The remaining 30% of Aquila shareholders have until 25 July to accept the $1.4b ($3.40 per share) bid.

Read the announcement and TIA here.

For further information, please contact Jay Leary, Partner, Brisbane, or your usual Herbert Smith Freehills contact.

26 June 2014

Clive Palmer and Al Gore team up in a remarkable day for carbon in Australia

Yesterday was a remarkable day here for carbon-related issues.

Clive Palmer has substantially changed position. He won’t support Direct Action - he says that it ‘is a waste of money’. Nor will he support the abolition of various key existing carbon-related statutory agencies or the Renewable Energy Target. What he now advocates is the implementation of an emissions trading scheme (ETS), but one which will be ‘zero-rated’ until Australia’s major trading partners (5  named countries including the US and China) have ‘equivalent’ schemes. He says that he will ‘move amendments’ to the Government’s Bills to do these things. He announced all of this to journalists gathered in the Great Hall of Parliament in the company of no less than Al Gore, both of whom left without taking or answering any questions. There will be plenty of them today.
 
It appears that he is now advocating a variation on what Rudd announced in July 2013 – an early move to the ‘flexible’ phase of carbon pricing, only a ‘zero-rated’ one. Milne of the Greens has picked up on this saying that she and her party will support moving to the market-based ‘flexible’ phase of carbon pricing under the Clean Energy Act in FY2014-2015 rather than FY2015-2016 as currently proposed.        

Labor has said this morning, through shadow environment Minister Mark Butler, that Labor went to the last election promising to get rid of the fixed carbon price and to move straight to the emissions trading scheme, and that it therefore has no trouble with the repeal of the fixed price but that it does have a problem with the repeal of a meaningful ETS.

Recently, Xenophon and others have made noises that the issues raised by the Government’s Bills are too complex and important to be decided in haste in the first weeks of a new Senate. Palmer’s actions yesterday will add weight to these calls.

Palmer’s position, if maintained, means that it’s likely that the Government’s Bills will be defeated in the Senate, a prospect which was unimaginable until yesterday.

Meanwhile, the Clean Energy Act remains in force unamended.

Stay tuned!

This article was written by John Taberner, Consultant, and Michael Voros, Special Counsel.

For further information, please contact John Taberner, Michael Voros, or your usual Herbert Smith Freehills contact.

13 June 2014

Bright future – the key factors driving economic growth in sub-Saharan Africa

The African market will continue to thrive thanks to increased availability of capital and investment in natural resources, power and infrastructure.

Since 2008 the world economy has undergone significant strain, which has had an effect on growth across all regions. However, in the face of these global headwinds, domestic supply shocks and civil conflict, Africa has been resilient. Of the 10 fastest-growing global economies in 2012, seven are in sub-Saharan Africa (SSA).

Natural resources
Persistently high commodity prices elsewhere in the world in recent years have resulted in renewed demand for Africa's abundant natural resources. This demand is evidenced by the increased foreign investment in the oil and gas sector in several SSA countries such as Kenya, Uganda and Mozambique, with relative success thus far.

Tullow drilling wells onshore in Turkana, Kenya have exhibited good results and declared commerciality with a circa 5,200 barrels-per-day flow rate; Mozambique has been the subject of a natural gas discovery of 100 trillion cubic feet (mainly in the offshore Rovuma Basin); and oil and gas exploration activities in Uganda have had an unprecedented 90% drilling success rate, with 58 of the 64 exploration and appraisal wells drilled in the country to date encountering oil and/or gas.

Accessibility to funding
The increased availability of capital for small and medium-sized enterprises has contributed to economic development in SSA by stimulating sectors that have traditionally been the backbone of growth in countries that do not rely on natural resources. For example, historically SSA's agricultural sector has struggled to access the financing required to sustain growth, with the cost of extending traditional banking infrastructures in rural areas deterring many banks and financial institutions from providing financing for the sector.
However, this gap has been filled, to a large extent, in recent years through private equity funding. This has become more available in SSA as governments move to relax or suspend laws that restrict repatriation of funds or impose currency controls. According to the Emerging Markets Private Equity Association, total private equity capital raised for SSA in 2012 was $1.4bn (£830.3m), with agribusiness proving one of the primary draws.

Infrastructure and power
Power and infrastructure has also become a key investment sector, and is both an opportunity for foreign investors and an essential ingredient in the continued development of many African countries. Interest in infrastructure investments seems only likely to grow, with recent figures from the Commonwealth Business Council showing an average 15%-20% return on investments in SSA infrastructure projects across all sectors.

Successful implementation of the Nigerian power sector privatisation – seen by many as one of the boldest privatisation initiatives in the global power industry over the last decade – may create further investment opportunities in SSA. Other countries may follow the lead of Nigeria and accept that, under certain circumstances, there is no continuing case for retention of infrastructure in public hands and that the constant need for state-owned enterprises to take into account non-commercial and political considerations will ultimately hinder the efficient provision of much-needed power and infrastructure, with consequential long-term detrimental impacts to the interests of consumers and taxpayers.

If continuous efforts to tackle poverty, corruption, inadequate infrastructures and political instability are successful in SSA, the region can expect to see continued economic growth.

This article was written by Gavin Davies, Partner, London and Aleem Tharani, Senior Associate, Kenya.

For further information, please contact Gavin Davies, Aleem Tharani or your usual Herbert Smith Freehills contact.

2 June 2014

The possible consequences of the termination of Indonesia’s Bilateral Investment Treaties

The Government of Indonesia recently indicated to the Dutch embassy in Jakarta that it intends on terminating all of its existing bilateral investment treaties starting with its treaty with the Netherlands. Indonesia has entered into bilateral investment treaties with over sixty counties including Australia, China, Singapore and the United Kingdom.

The outright removal of any future treaty protection for investments in Indonesia is of considerable concern to existing and prospective investors. In the absence of this treaty protection, the only remaining recourse for many investors are the Indonesian courts or diplomatic channels.

Some commentators have suggested that Indonesia instead intends to use the termination as a means of renegotiating the terms of all the bilateral investment treaties. However this appears unlikely as it would involve separate discussions with over sixty nations regarding investment protections.

If Indonesia did terminate all of its bilateral investment treaties without substituting them for alternative arrangements, the consequences for investors would not be immediate. Many of the bilateral investment treaties will still not expire for a number of years and Indonesia is not able to terminate them until their expiry. Further, many bilateral investment treaties have 'sunset periods' during which investors can continue to rely on the protections in the treaty.

Indonesia continues to be a signatory to a number of multilateral investment treaties. These will continue to afford protection to investors through international tribunals. The protections and dispute resolution mechanisms under Indonesian investment law also continue to apply.

Despite there being a number of alternative protections for investors, this recent news changes the investment landscape in Indonesia. Investors are advised to carefully consider how their investments are structured in order to ensure that they remain protected in the future.

The full article, written by Haydn Dare is available here.

For further information, please contact Haydn Dare, Senior International Counsel, Jakarta or your usual Herbert Smith Freehills and Hiswara Bunjamin & Tandjung contact.